Opinion 
 Blogs 
 The Square Eye 
 REVIEW: Top Gear Australia (part 2) 

REVIEW: Top Gear Australia (part 2)

IT seems nearly everyone has an opinion about Top Gear Australia - most of it being negative.

My review of the debut episode attracted 27 comments. The detractors used terms such as "wannabe'', "very disappointed'' and "kinda crap and a little dull'' while a minority said the Aussie version should be given time to settle.

Well, we're six weeks on from the first episode, so I thought I'd run the rule over the show again.

The three presenters, Warren Brown, Charlie Cox and Steve Pizzati, seemed a little nervous first-up trying to balance the need to be respectful to the British original and be uniquely Australian.

Weeks later, when you look at it as a show in its own right, they haven't done that bad a job, but when compared the original, there's still work to be done. That was to be expected, considering how good Clarkson and co. are.

It was good to see parts of Australia being showcased during challenges, such as the Whitsundays and the outback.

A highlight though was Steve and Warren driving a tractor down Toorak Rd and damaging a car while trying to reserve park. Anything to make us low to middle class types feel better.

The "What we're they thinking'' segment (some would argue what was SBS thinking allowing for the show in the first place) was a trip down memory lane for some motoring enthusiasts, but seemed a little awkward to watch at times.

Yes, it's not as good as the UK version, but remember, even Clarkson, May and Hammond needed time to settle. Just look at their original efforts in this studio format (Top Gear had been a 30-minute magazine-style show for 24 years) to know what I'm talking about.

But the good news for fans of the UK Top Gear is that SBS will be screening new episodes from Monday, November 24 after the first season of the Aussie version ends.

If you didn't like Top Gear Australia, imagine what the Americans will do when their version begins next year.

What do you think, has Top Gear Australia improved at all over the last couple of weeks?

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Nope. It's still appalling! To SBS: Where's the sense in wasting taxpayer money on a poor copy? Everyone keeps saying "give them time to settle in, because the UK version took a long time to settle in", but that type of thinking is completely redundant because this is a DIRECT copy of a mature and proven version of an excellent show. Or am I the only one that has managed to spot that fact?
Posted by Sanity, 12/11/2008 1:26:32 AM
When you try and recreate a show such as Top Gear, a show with a cult like following, with new presenters in another country, criticism is inevitible. Top Gear is a world wide franchise and to use that name you are limited to a certain degree with how different you can make it from the original. I think with those limitations in place SBS and the three Aussie presenters have done a good job. We are lucky we get the best of both worlds Holden V Ford challenges on Top Gear Australia, then Classic Top Gear returning next week with Clarkson and the boys.
Posted by Justin, 18/11/2008 7:00:10 PM
I was wondering whether the top gear people could deive a few cars to wycliffe well in the Northern territory to try to chase a few UFO's and try to send someone up to grab on to it please.
Posted by Anda , 24/11/2008 7:10:17 PM
I'd agree with Justin, (post no 2). Although only still relativity new TG QZ needs to pick up its game a bit!@! And when are they going to give real opinions on what they thinks about a car like Clarkeston does. Show Aussie stuff e.g compare the new F6 to the Maloo properly( or GTS if you like)
Posted by cliff, 18/12/2008 2:39:11 PM
The Square Eye
David Braithwaite runs his eye over the best and worst in TV.

Most popular articles

Yourguide to Your Toyota
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...