News 
 Local News 
 Sport 
 Cricket 
 Lizards `perplexed' at SMCA decision 

Lizards `perplexed' at SMCA decision

04 Sep, 2009 05:00 AM
SALE CITY Cricket Club has been left "perplexed'' by a Sale-Maffra Cricket Association decision to cut it from first grade this season.

Only eight clubs will contest first grade this season, with Sale City relegated to remove the need for a bye.

Eight clubs will also contest second grade, while there will be two fourth grade competitions - one with a mixture of 60-over two-day and 40-over one-day matches, the other entirely of one-day games in previous seasons.

Sale City president Les Abel said the SMCA committee had not thought through the move to cut the firsts down to eight teams.

"It was apparent at the SMCA annual general meeting that the current committee was hell-bent on dropping the bye from the draw, what they haven't considered is the effect of such a decision has on a club,'' he said.

Abel said the SMCA move compromised the club's efforts to foster young players instead of focussing on results.

"Since the decision was made by the club it has done the hard yards of waiting for the players to mature into senior cricketers and last season was competitive in the first innings, but the immaturity of the playing group meant they could not press home an advantage,'' he said.

"The club could live with the (SMCA) decision if it was voted on by all clubs, not a select group of clubs that currently form the committee. The club representation is unbalanced on the committee with some clubs having two or three representative and other clubs not being able to get onto the committee.''

Sale City had a nomination for the committee, but was unsuccessful.

Now without first grade side of their own, the Lizards have struck an agreement with Traralgon and District association club Imperials.

"We will use the Traralgon club as our first grade team, the players that are batting well and bowling well, will be offered promotion to the Traralgon club on a weekly basis and if they wish to continue playing in Traralgon, they will be offered one-year clearances to that club to continue their careers,'' Abel said.

"The player group have said they would not feel right to go and play at clubs in the SMCA that have voted us out of first grade.''

SMCA president Dean Benson said the decision was made based on feedback from clubs.

"The feedback we've got since I've been on the committee is the clubs didn't want the bye ... and they're not keen on Sunday cricket,'' he said.

"Sale City's results over the last two years have lead us down this path.''

Sale City has not won a first grade game since season 2006-7.

Benson said the association wanted a good standard of cricket with appropriate gradings, but admitted tough decisions had to be made.

For Sale City to come back up, Benson said another club would need to join it.

That may be difficult, last year the association unsuccessfully attempted to elevate Heyfield back into first grade, a move resisted by the club as it wasn't able to field a top grade team at short notice.

Benson responded to the Lizards' junior argument by pointing to the College Junior Football Club.

"College has a got a few junior footy sides, but they don't have a senior affiliation. Mum and dad are not going to worry about seniors,'' he said.

"(Sale City's) juniors are a long way off playing senior cricket.''

Benson said it was up the Lizards to prove they're worthy for firsts by performing well in the seconds.

The SMCA committee is waiting on feedback from clubs before it decides on the structure for the four senior grades. A decision should be made on Wednesday.

"A lot of clubs have come back and said they want to play their kids in the two-day comp,'' Benson said.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
So what does the "S" in SMCA stand for then? With backwards thinking like this in Gippsland sport it's surprising our talented up coming youngsters are able to make it into the elite sporting arena. Seriously the committee needs to get rid of this old boys club mentality that seems to revolve around about what your surname is rather than fostering community minded spirit. Didn't realise in my youth after playing for 12 years in the junior and senior level in the SMCA how political this all was, amnd apparently nothing has changed.
Posted by Former Local, 8/09/2009 1:54:17 PM
Why has the SMCA not made minutes of the most recent AGM available? I was not at the meeting but have been told that Sale City CC's nominations for the committee were not accepted for dubious reasons. Make your minutes available so people can judge whether the committee's election complies with the constitution.
Posted by Former SMCA comittee member, 17/09/2009 10:37:08 PM

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.

Most popular articles

Yourguide to Your Toyota
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...